CI: A Letter to My Son

Criminal InJustice is a weekly series devoted to taking action against inequities in the U.S. criminal justice system. Nancy A. Heitzeg, Professor of Sociology and Race/Ethnicity, is the Editor of CI. Criminal InJustice is published every Wednesday at 6 pm CST.

A Letter to My Son
by princss6

Here is my testimony – a letter from an African American Mother to her only son.

My job – is to protect you from any and all who would seek to harm you, demean you, treat you as less than any other child. Yep, that is my job and let me tell you son, why the world, this society, this state and city makes it so difficult. Bottom-line, black life isn’t worth much. It never has been in this country and I’m concerned that it never will be. So let me offer my apology first to you for knowing that the world I want for you, is not the world you will inherit. Let me apologize to you for pushing you so hard, because I know other children with your same make-up and profile but with different skin color will have life immeasurably easy because they won’t have to, day in and day out, continue to prove, they aren’t stupid, dumb, incompetent, criminal, lascivious and lazy. I’m sorry but I love you and you give my life meaning.

But let me tell you a history of your life and why it is so important that you understand the constraints you face. You see, I was born in 1970. Your family is large though not as close as it used to be when you were younger. But before, I was born, tragedy struck. I won’t go too much into the details, but homicide has been familiar to this family for so long. Your great-aunt, on your grandfather’s side was murdered with five arrows by her husband. Two children were left to deal with the ensuing trauma and raised by your paternal grandmother. One of the two children is still with us. After serving a few years in jail and a week after his release, the son of your great aunt was murdered, shot with a gun and died. Gone. Full circle, mother killed with bow and arrow by her husband, her husband divined the fate of your cousin when while killing his wife, he attempted to suffocate his own infant son who went on at the age of 25 to have the life suffocated out of him by a murder’s gun. Yes, this is all your history but I will not let it define you. Later, your maternal grandmother’s first cousin, a black man, with several children of his own was stabbed and killed in a bar. Yes, this trauma shaped the egg and the sperm that met to make me.

And before you were even born, your Uncle, who would have been such a great example for you was murdered, shot in the head, futilely left on life support when there was no hope, at all. I got the call when I was in North Carolina. I had dreamt something horrible happening two nights in a row before getting the call. I got that call early in the morning and well, I hope you never receive a call like that ever in your life. I hope you never know the feeling of mortality, the isolation, the aloneness that I feel. It was around the time that it became an obsession for me, thinking about who would be there to care for me in the end. Would I die alone? Fortunately, your uncle didn’t die alone. As I rushed home on Amtrak, praying against all hope that he would be okay, I had a headache that was unlike any other headache I’d ever experienced. It lasted for hours and then it went away. It was a headache that both me and my sister and my brother shared as my brother hung to life through a ventilator as his brain swelled. When he was moved from life support, while I was making my way home, and his life ended, my headache stopped. It just stopped. And with the headache leaving, so did your Uncle. And it was a salient and profound recognition that we were connected and that connection was gone forever.

So a few years later, when a man that I was dating, you don’t remember him because you were young, was missing, it never dawned on me that anything could be horribly wrong. I mean, how much death could there be out there for me? The phone calls that weren’t returned for days, until one day, I received a phone call at work saying that my friend, I was just getting to care for was in the morgue. Another young black man, gunned down, found not far from where I was living. He also left three children who had to mourn his loss. Christmas is always a reminder of that time I spent not able to get out of the bed, beside myself because, well, losing a loved one (which I have) via sickness is difficult. Losing someone who you just spoke to, trying to remember your last conversation, wondering about their fear when they knew what was inevitable, and their last moments, well, it brings me to my knees even today. And not knowing who, who, would pull the trigger purposely, was it a neighbor, someone you see on the street, did I have anything to fear….the thoughts are endless and there are no answers even as time passes…still no answers.

And remember that day this summer when you were supposed to come home from your grandfather’s and I told you to stay a few days longer. On that day, this summer, a man was shot on our street in a broad daylight, five doors down. Another young black man. His body lay on the street for hours until it was processed and removed. He was gunned down while riding his bike, for what reason I don’t know. I had nightmares that night and I’m only glad I didn’t go to the door immediately when I heard the gunshots. Because being a witness to a crime is dangerous and doing the right thing isn’t easy in these circumstances. And coming face-to-face with a murderer is something that would shake anyone to their core. So I waited to hear sirens. No sirens but glancing up later, I saw police lights and guessed it was safe to look out. There under a white, blood-stained sheet was someone’s son! I’m sure just as lovable and charming and LOVED as you are but in these matters, none of that resonates. In these matters, life and its value do not matter. You and so many others like you have thoroughly been objectified, dehumanized, criminalized, policed, mystified and mythologized so that the police just file murders like these away and chalk them up as the inevitable. The inevitable for little boys that grow up to be men who are either criminalized and incarcerated, killed with no justice seekers and/or ignored and deemed not worthy and/or employable.

So son, when I went to find this article that I read on Friday and I see this headline…

“4 killed in separate Philadelphia shootings

Four men were killed Sunday in separate shootings across Philadelphia, police said.

That relates to this article –

Study: PA has second-highest rate of black homicide victims

Pennsylvania has the second-highest rate of black homicide victims in the nation, according to a study released today by the Violence Policy Center in Washington, D.C.

The study looked at 2008 FBI data and found that 449 of the state’s homicide victims that year were black, which resulted in a black homicide rate of 31.05 per 100,000. Numbers for Philadelphia were not immediately available.

That relates to this article –

Police name 7 slain in 3 days

Homicide detectives are looking for the shooters who killed seven men in separate attacks around Philadelphia since noon Friday.
The killings bring to 24 the number of people slain in the city this year, not including the woman and seven infants allegedly killed by abortion doctor Kermit Gosnell and whose deaths are counted in the police homicide statistics.

How do I keep you safe? Will I ever have peace of mind? Young and old black men die from homicide every day. How do I do my job which is to protect you so you can go on to great things? How do I keep you from believing (because believing is wish fulfillment) that your fate is to be a chalk outline in a street one day? What do I have to do to keep you from being just another statistic, another dead black young man? How do I explain that store clerks, no longer find you the cutest charming child who they allow to ring up items, that now they see you worthy of tailing and shadowing in their stores? How can I show you that many will project their sexual fantasies on to you and degrade and dehumanize you for folly? How do I teach you about the projection of others inadequacies onto you? How do I show you that even though they fear you, you have far more to fear from them they would ever from you? How do I impress upon you that you do not get the benefit of the doubt like your white friends and peers? And how do I keep you from raging against this, rebelling against this no win situation when you begin to see what it is I’m telling you? Do you know why I’m so hard on you? Do you understand that when you are not with me, when you walk out the door and I can’t jump in front of any weapon formed against you, you are as vulnerable as the day you were born? And do you know that what is outside is much harsher and will have more consequences than anything you experience at home? And do you know how powerless that makes me feel? Do you know and understand that I have to think about this every day, son?

It is not your fault and I hold no resentment towards you. But I resent the hell out of a society that cares nothing for you and those like you because of your skin color and your gender. I resent that you can’t go and be free because of the lessons, I’ve learned, the people I’ve lost , the people you’ve lost that could have helped shape your life. And more importantly because this society is completely tolerable of letting their young black men waste away. Not only does this society tolerate it, it demands it.

I don’t want you to grow cynical like me but I embrace my cynicism for your life. Because yes, son, I’ve been through a lot and I’ve seen some bad days, but as God is my witness, I fight for your life because I’m fighting for mine because God knows that when you leave this earth, I’ll be right behind you because there is no me without you.

So son, we are in this together. When you grow, I grow. When you thrive, I thrive. When you hurt, I hurt. But despite it all, through the good and the bad, I know God put me on this earth to be your Mom.


How beautiful if nothing more
Than to wait at Zion’s door
I’ve never been in love like this before
Now let me pray to keep you from
The perils that will surely come
See life for you my prince has just begun
And I thank you for choosing me
To come through unto life to be
A beautiful reflection of his grace
See I know that a gift so great
Is only one God could create
And I’m reminded every time I see your face

To Zion, Lauryn Hill

Signed,
Mom

(28)

  • Nanette

    Beautiful and heartbreaking, princss6. Thank you for sharing it.

    • Hi Nanette!

      Thank you for reading!  It is good to see you!

  • Anonymous

    Hi princss6

    a beautiful, loving letter….thank you

    • Hi foufou!  So good to see you!  Thanks you.

  • poco

    Hello CI! Sorry I am  so late reading this.

    princss, that is a very powerful and extraordinarily moving letter that you have written. Reading it is like experiencing heartbreak; came close to tears a number of times. I really wish there would be a world where you did not have to write such a letter.

    Much respect to you and all who work to make that world become more of a possibility.

    • amen poco!

      great to see you — any time

      thanks

    • Hi poco!  I’m glad you made it over and thank you for reading!  

      • poco

        Thanks, nancy and princss6.

        Re the MHP blow up–gotta say the response on DKos prepared me for the blowback.

        There was a diary in which sybil liberty (I think) had a comment listing a number of examples of Rovian and RW trolls using emo-prog language to spread dissension and confusion by attacking OBH. S/He provided links and I went and read each one–all of them were unmasked and banned, but all the usual suspects had recc’d and tipped them. Got to acknowledge I was shocked at the number of the trolls and the amount of support they received. The fact there is a concerted effort underway to undermine support of the president is undeniable.

        Gotta admit, I was one of those emo-progs for a while (my issues are Gitmo, Civil liberties, I/P, American imperialism) and it has taken me a while to understand that easy slogans, and easy condemnations add to the problem, not to the solution.

        I really think MHP has taken on a huge fight and I will be in her corner for the duration. 

         

  • Must read article…

    http://www.angryblacklady.com/2011/09/28/gene-lyons-of-salon-com-cavalierly-dismisses-racism-and-calls-melissa-harris-perry-is-a-fool/#comment-19193

    It is unbelievable to me that in this day and age, some on the white Left are really going to allow race to fracture the Democratic Party.  But one question that needs to be answered, are the Media Elite, really a part of the Democratic Party?

    They’ve built their platforms and slowly but determinedly they are shutting those platform to black/white/supporters of the President and anti-racists.  It happened with WEESeeYou where supporters of the President were shut out.  And had to go start another blog.  We saw it at DailyKos where the President’s most vocal and anti-racist supporters were banned.  

    Now Salon is pulling the faux-populism (and anyone who knows about the history of this country knows that populism is nothing more than white solidarity) where a bunch of white left elites are going to stoke racial resentment among whites to put the Black Man in his place.

    I shouldn’t be surprised but the brazenness in which this is all being undertaken is stunning.  The writing is on the wall folks!

    • Anonymous

      This is the old southern strategy, Amirah.  I’m not convinced that Democrats are behind it – it’s very Lee Atwater, and I would guess that there are folks gaming within Dem circles who do not have Democratic Party interests at heart.

      And are resorting to time-tested race-baiting strategies. 

      • I agree, I don’t think Democrats are behind this and I think they are posers thus my question.

  • Aji

    Hi, All ~

    Sorry I’m so late.  Four things:

    1) To princss6, thank you for posting this again.  Should be required reading for everyone, and I hope you repost it far and wide.  Blessings to you and your beautiful son.

    2) To Nancy and Kay, many thanks, as always, for your tireless work here, and to my little sis Seeta for giving it a new home (and a great blog all the way around!).

    3) Seeta, I’m sorry I’m not around more, but disqus and my laptop apparently hate each other.  Most of the time, I can’t even load an entire post, much less comments.  At my wit’s end.

    4) Since I don’t know how long I’ll be able to comment, I hope no one minds if I post this here.  (Apologies if it’s already been posted; I can’t scroll through comments very well.)  But I learned via Emily Hauser at Angry Black Lady Chronicles that Troy Davis’s family cannot afford to give him a proper funeral, so some folks are raising funds.  For anyone interested in donating, preliminary instructions are at the post linked here:  http://www.angryblacklady.com/2011/09/28/troy-davis-%e2%80%93-funeral-expenses/.  (Apologies again; I don’t know how to embed links in disqus.)  We’re in for a small amount – too small, but I guess every little bit helps.

    Love to you all.

    • Love to you Aji — a vision!

      I will see if i can some tips frm seeta and pass them in re Disqus.. emptying my cache helped me a great deal;

      Thank you for the troy davis info also — yes..

    • Anonymous

      Hey, Aji, so good to see you.  I had disqus problems, too and will touch base about how I waded through the tangle.

      Isn’t seeta’s blog terrific?  I really love the intersectional approach and spirit.  And the statement of values and principles.  I’m stopping here daily now to “read the news.”

      Thank you for the Troy Davis funeral link.  Heartbreak upon tragedy upon injustice upon heartbreak.

      Sending love.

  • Anonymous

    Thank you for a beautiful and moving piece

    • it truly is

      wonderful to see you Robinswing — always

    • Hi Robin.  Thank you for reading.

  • blue jersey mom

    Thank you for posting this.

    • Anonymous

      Hi, bjm.  Great to see you tonight.  Thanks for stopping by.

    • and thank you for being here bjm

      much appreciated

  • Anonymous

    p6 — One of the most beautiful things I’ve ever read. Blessed be the mothers and their children. Thank you again for this wonderful piece.

    • Hey, RubyR!

      Good to see you and thank you for reading.  

    • Anonymous

      Hi, ruby!  Yes, this is a remarkable letter from a wonderful mom to a beautiful son.  

    • Blessed Be Ruby

      thank you !

  • Emmet

    Beautiful, tragic and strong, princss6.   One can bear injustice to oneself, but to one’s child…  Your son is lucky to have you.

    • Anonymous

      Thanks for being here, Emmet.  Good to see you.

      Yes, princss6’s love for her son can inspire us all.

      Sending you ever good thought/wish.

    •  Yes..

      thank you Emmet – appreciate you being here

    • Thank you, Emmet.  I hope all is well with you.

      • Emmet

        Could be worse.  Could be much worse.  And Thanksgiving is coming!

  • Last week we were awaiting word on Troy Davis

    May the Movement towards Abolition continue in His Name

    http://www.democracynow.org/2011/9/26/martina_correia_on_execution_of_troy

    • Amen!

    • Anonymous

      So sad.  Talk about having a lot of work to do.

  • Sam …

    Hi all, this is unspeakable. I only realized this was the new home for the series this past week. So glad that the series is going strong.

    Thank you, princss, for sharing this deeply heartfelt and heartbreaking letter. No child should ever have to learn these “facts of life,” but your son is so lucky to have a mother so brave and so wise to help him along the way. Hugs!

    • Anonymous

      ahhhh, Sam/unspeakable, so wonderful to see you here! 

      princss’ diary is so powerful and important.

    • so great to see you!!!

      hope you are a weekly fixture here

    • (((unspeakable))))

      Thank you.  You are so appreciated.  And much respect and gratitude to you.

    • Good to see you here unspeakable!

  • Patriotdaily

    such a powerful letter with sadness, but also a letter full of love and wisdom.

    • Anonymous

      Loving seeing you tonight, Patriotdaily.

      Thanks.

      Sending all warm regards. 

      • Patriotdaily

        great to see you and nancy, and everyone too. so glad you guys continued with ci. it was one of my favs at DK. the topic is so important and the writing also so outstanding. It just breaks my heart that so many of the issues of today are the same issues i taught back in the 198os when i was in law school. 

        • Anonymous

          Thanks for having taught these issues, dear friend.

          I am sending you every good wish.  It’s so wonderful seeing you.  Don’t want to lose touch. 

        • Anonymous

          great to see you here!

        • Great to see you here Patriotdaily!

    • amen to all of it..

      thank you Patriotdaily

      always so great too see

    • Thank, PD and thank you for reading.

  • Anonymous

    that’s required reading material right there.  and i don’t mean those likely to read it.

    wow, princss6!  just wow.

  • For our lurkers:  L’Shana Tova to all celebrating.

    • Anonymous

      L’shana tova tikatevu.

      • Anonymous

        the message from my daughter’s head of school today said: 

        “We heartily wish one another a happy, sweet New Year, confident in
        God’s protection and forgiveness.  Indeed, we praise God each day in our morning
        services as one who is mechadesh be-tuvo bechol yom Ma’aseh Bereshit, who
        renews the Creation each day anew.  At this time of the year, as we celebrate
        that Creation, singing zeh hayom techilat ma’asecha, zikaron le-yom rishon,”
        today is the anniversary of the start of your work, a commemoration of the
        first day.” ”

        Which reminded me of the text that says, basically, just because the work of healing the world is too big for one person, it is not a justification for abandoning that work. Putting it together, it seems proper to start the year by re-dedicating. 

        Much respect and love to you.
         

        • Anonymous

          I love the message and the text you note:  yes.  Just because the healing is too big for any of us, that does not mean we should step back.  It is all the more reason to step forward, with joy and determination.

          Much respect and love to you.

        • thank you sberel

          so much — great to see you

        • Thank you sberel…tikkun olam.

  • Anonymous

    You know that I read this the first time around… still, I’m reading it again, and it hurts as much as before.

    I tried so hard to protect my son because I had some idea of what he would be up against.  A lot of the protection was watching, and warning, and pushing him to be as perfect as he could be because, maybe, that would be the different little bit of something that would carry him through to adulthood.

    Now, he is an adult with a college degree but he is still a Black man in this society when he is waiting in line at the airport, or walking over to the basketball court, or stepping on an elevator.

    We still have a lot of work to do.

    • Hi Sage!  That’s the scary part.  We never stop worrying.  They never cease being threats, especially among strangers in strange places.

    • Anonymous

      powerfully said, sage. 

    • Hey sage — this is very painful to read, indeed.  We’ve got to do better than this — that includes dismantling racist archetypes and dismantling the PIC and the racist archetypes that feed/fuel it.

      • Anonymous

        So, true.  There are so many traps laid out there from the time they are born.

        The Black man archetype in American society is powerful and hard to pull down…. even when we are looking at a sweet-faced eight or ten year old Black boy… others see some latent violent “other” waiting for a chance to do something bad.

        • Anonymous

          A foundational archetype, embedded in the structure of the criminal legal system.  A racist archetype to its core.

        • foundational everywhere

          as we have recently witnessed

          your kids are lucky sage — thank you

  • Thank you princss for sharing this heart-wrenching, powerful, moving letter with us.  It saddens me deeply that a child needs to learn these realities. 

    • Thank you, seeta for providing a safe space for my voice.

      • I am honored to be graced by your powerful voice here princss.  Deeply honored.  It pains me that you had to write this letter to your son.  Infinite respect for you sister.

    • so true seeta

      thank you as always for this wonderful space

  • Anonymous

    Wow. What a powerful and sorrowful post. I feel speechless and ashamed of my country for allowing such tragedy to become a way of life for an entire people.

    • Hi Trashablanca!  Thank you so much for reading and more importantly being moved by my story, my life.

    • Anonymous

      hi, trashablanca, good to see you.  Sending warm greetings.

    • Amen

      thanks as always for stopping

    • Hi trashablanca!  It is shameful indeed.  I can only hope — who knows, perhaps 100 yrs from now maybe (???) — maybe a different type of letter might be written to young black male children. 

  • Thanks, CI Editors and of course our lovely and gracious host, Seeta!

    • Anonymous

      Cheers to seeta, not only for CI, but for this entire blog, which is the blog I’ve been dreaming of! 

      • Yes!  So dense with important information!  So much respect for Seeta in creating this space.

    • Thank you princss for sharing this heart-wrenching letter with us.  Shared far and wide.  Sometimes there just are no words –> ::huge hug here:::

  • thank you princss

    every time i read this — just so many emotions..

    so much sadness that you would need to write such a letter at all..

    so much joy for you and Zion that your love enables you to do so

    Gratitude — always

    This should be read world-wide

  • Anonymous

    Princss6, this is an amazingly powerful and prophetic diary.  

    And it is painful.

    But you lay out the reasons why we are fighting.

    Much love, endless respect.

    To you and your son:  I will never stop fighting to abolish the prison industrial complex and the structural racism upon which it is built.  

    • Much love and respect to you, Kay.  Always!

      And much gratitude to you for fighting when it is tough and not convenient.

      • Anonymous

        Convenient?  What is this word of which you speak? 

        • So many of us could take the road of least convenience.  You, along with others I had close and dear do not.  I respect that about you.

          • Anonymous

            backatcha.

  • Yasuragi

    Gotta run, but wanted to rec/like this wonderful piece (again) — brilliant.

    • thank you!!

      appreciate you stopping yas

    • Anonymous

      Good to see you, Yas!  Thanks for being here.  

    • Hey Yas!